How to Compare Roofing Bids in Florida
By Donald Storm, Florida licensed roofing contractor · Updated November 17, 2026
To compare roofing bids, line up the same scope, materials, warranties, schedule and license for each one instead of looking only at the total. A bid that seems better can leave out the permit, the dumpster or a real warranty, so check what is included first.
Start by making sure every bid covers the same job
Comparing roofing bids only works when every roofer is bidding on the same work. A bid that looks better on paper may simply cover less. Before you judge anything else, confirm that each bid describes the same scope.
Ask each roofer to put the details in writing. If one bid is a single line and another is a full page, ask the short one to fill in the gaps. Here is what to look for on every bid:
- Tear-off: whether old roofing is removed down to the deck.
- Decking: how rotted or damaged wood is handled, and how it is charged if found mid-job.
- Underlayment: the type and brand being installed.
- Flashing, drip edge, vents and pipe boots: replaced or reused.
- Shingle line: the manufacturer and product, not just "architectural shingles."
- Permit and dumpster: whether each is included or left for you to arrange.
- Cleanup: how debris and loose nails are handled when the job ends.
Look at what the price includes, not only the price
Two totals are only comparable when they include the same things. The most common gaps are the permit, debris removal and wood repair. If a bid leaves these out, you may end up paying for them separately later.
Ask every roofer how change orders work. Roofs sometimes reveal hidden damage once the old shingles come off. A good roofer explains up front how that is identified, documented and priced, and gets your approval before doing extra work.
Also compare the payment terms side by side:
- How large the deposit is and what it is used for.
- When the balance is due.
- Whether materials are paid for before they are delivered.
- What happens if the schedule slips or the scope changes.
Verify the license and ask for proof of insurance
A bid is only as good as the company behind it. Every bid should show a Florida contractor license number. Look it up at myfloridalicense.com and confirm that the name matches the company on the bid, the license is active and the license type fits roofing work.
Ask for proof of insurance as well, and make sure it is current. A reputable roofer will send it without fuss. If someone avoids the question or says they will get to it later, treat that as a signal.
If your roof job is tied to an insurance claim, ask your insurance company about what is covered. Keep copies of every bid, photo and piece of paperwork so the claim file is complete.
Read the warranties closely
Roofing bids usually mention two kinds of warranty, and they are not the same thing.
The workmanship warranty comes from the roofer. It covers how the roof was installed. The material warranty comes from the manufacturer, or is described by the roofer, and it covers the shingles themselves. Because the material warranty is often stated by the roofer, ask for the actual manufacturer paperwork if you want to see the terms.
When you compare warranties, ask these questions:
- How long does the workmanship warranty last?
- What does it cover, and what voids it?
- Is it transferable if you sell your home?
- Who do you call if there is a leak, and how fast do they respond?
- Does the roofer have a track record of staying in business to honor it?
Compare the schedule, not just the paperwork
Start date and production days matter, especially in Florida where weather and storm season can shift plans. Ask each roofer when they can begin and how many working days the job should take. A roofer with an open schedule is not automatically better than a busy one, but the dates should be realistic and written down.
Pay attention to how each roofer communicates while you are collecting bids. Do they answer questions clearly? Do they explain the process without pressure? Their behavior before you sign is a good preview of how the job will go.
Be cautious if you see any of these:
- Pressure to sign today or lose the offer.
- A request for a large payment before any paperwork is signed.
- A vague scope with no materials named.
- No license number, or one that does not check out.
- A bid that is far apart from the others with no clear reason.
How RoofWyze makes bids easier to compare
RoofWyze is a Florida roof replacement marketplace. You request bids for free, and licensed, insured roofers bid on your job. You can receive up to 3 sealed bids, and bidding stays open for up to 72 hours, so you are not chasing roofers or sitting through sales visits.
Every bid is laid out the same way. Each one shows the roofer's price, start date, production days, workmanship warranty, material warranty as stated by the roofer, and Florida license number. Every bid also includes the permit and the dumpster, which removes two of the biggest gaps from the comparison.
Your privacy is protected while you decide. Roofers see only your ZIP code and roof data. Your name, street address and contact information stay hidden until you choose a roofer and materials are delivered.
Once you pick a bid, you choose your shingle brand and color one time, on the Confirm screen, from the brands that roofer offers. You pay a deposit to RoofWyze, which is the roofer's deposit percentage and at least 50%. RoofWyze holds it, and materials are paid from it after the roofer confirms the delivered materials are correct. You pay the roofer the balance directly.
You also get a 3-business-day cancel window after signing, and materials are not ordered until it ends. After the window, cancelling costs a $500 commitment fee plus any materials already ordered.
Ready to see real bids side by side? Get free bids at roofwyze.com/start.
Frequently asked questions
How many roofing bids should I get?
Three is a good number. It gives you enough to spot an unusual bid without becoming overwhelming. On RoofWyze, you can receive up to 3 sealed bids per job.
Is the cheapest roofing bid the best one?
Not always. A lower bid may leave out the permit, the dumpster, decking repair or a solid warranty. Compare scope, materials, warranties and the roofer's license before you decide on price alone.
How do I check a Florida roofer's license?
Go to myfloridalicense.com and search by license number or business name. Confirm the license is active and that the name matches the company on the bid.
What is the difference between a workmanship warranty and a material warranty?
A workmanship warranty comes from the roofer and covers the installation. A material warranty covers the shingles themselves. Ask for the written terms of both.
Can I cancel after I sign a roofing contract on RoofWyze?
Yes. You have a 3-business-day cancel window after signing, and materials are not ordered until it ends. After that, cancelling costs a $500 commitment fee plus any materials already ordered.
Do roofers see my address when they bid on RoofWyze?
No. Roofers see only your ZIP code and roof data. Your name, street address and contact information stay hidden until you choose a roofer and materials are delivered.
Get up to 3 sealed bids from licensed, insured roofers.
Get free bids